As I sit down tonight it looks as if the Tea Parties were a success. Especially when compared to the lame A New Way Forward events, which fizzled out like stale Coke. Again, let me repeat: the issue with the Condescension Class on the Left is an ongoing refusal to see the central fact- Obama stands opposed to the goals of A New Way Forward. Until they understand that Obama is "working for the man" the Right will be able to seize the high ground. Like it or not. By ignoring the truth about Obama for going on years now the "left" has boxed itself in.
The White House was "locked down" briefly. A p.r. win - if nothing else. Most rallies where directed at Obama, though they were to be "non- partisan." It is hard to asses the ongoing effectiveness of the Tea Party movement. What is worth stating - and quite clear now - is that the energy surrounding Obama just 90 days ago has faded abruptly. BHO, by tentatively staking out the alleged middle - betraying his promise of real change - and by coddling the bankers has blown yet another chance at change. Had he taken major steps to reign in the worst banks early on the Left who believed the worst banks should have been nationalized - myself included - would have a true rallying point. Obama demurred and now the Maddow/Huffington Left has been reduced to obnoxious snarking just 2 months after peaking.
Important points:
1. The anger today was focused on Obama.
(I interject my rewrite here: I should have said - "Obama stands to lose the most. Naturally anger will be directed at the man in power now." Also - BHO has promoted an agenda of spending that even made some of the most cynical Americans blanch. In other words - blow back against government spending has been given a large target in the last 2 months. Both Zombie and Jeannie pointed out in comments that I was off in the rather blunt #1 assessment. Tea Parties are clearly not a solely an anti-Obama phenomenon. They are, however, in many ways fueled by Obama's bailout plans and startlingly large budget blueprint. )
This can't be stated enough: with breathtaking speed a chunk of the population has galvanized against the person who is now in the White House. This may not be fair - but it will continue. 2. The GOP stands to benefit here, especially if the economy continues to creak. 3. Those of us who are anti-Obama liberals (I borrow Cannonfire's term - and suggest a read of this post.) must take care to avoid association with the loopiest elements of the Tea Party folks. I have great sympathy for what occurred today because I see it as blow back against both Obama and Bush.
the message was rather consistent and the tone hostile: they are very upset with the current administration and Congress' handling of fiscal and economic issues. But Republicans should not be rejoicing quite yet. Many protesters went out of their way to say they are upset with both parties and hold George W. Bush equally responsible for launching the now never-ending stream of bailouts.
The simplest way to stay clear headed and not allow the worst elements of the Right to re-emerge, while at the same time standing against Obama's fecklessness in the face of bankster criminality is to remember: Obama, like Bush, is a working for the elite class doing the looting.
Obama, unlike McCain, was the natural inheritor of George W Bush's mantle. Both men personify the problem.Labels: Arianna Huffington, Barack Obama, faux left, george w bush, John McCain, protest, rachel maddow, tea parties
The most damaging addiction of those on the Left is not taxing and spending - it is condescension.
I must admit, the Tea Parties set for this week have not been of much interest to me until Krugman weirdly joined up with the condescension class bent of looking down their snouts at them. He also misreads the impulse behind the movement. It saddens me to see him participate in what Kunstler calls media "auditing" . The meme in the "liberal" media is that the Tea Parties are either meaningless or sponsored by the DARK SIDE - read: Fox News and ultra Right wingers who live in gated enclaves watching CSPAN while steam comes out of their ears, all the while writing checks to hatchet men. These criticisms from the Maddows of the Media are leveled without the slightest question as to where Chicago Slim's millions came from. A mystery, indeed.
Creating a "movement" with Astroturfing ( public relations campaigns seeking to create the impression of being spontaneous "grassroots" behavior,) works if the movement wants to be created. That is - it has a ready audience. At the end of the day people need to show up to the "astroturfed movement". If enough do, it is a success. At that point, there is no contradiction between "astroturfing" and "grass roots" eruptions. If 20,000 show up to the Tea Party on Wednesday in NY it is because they chose to, not because Fox News made them.
My sense is that there is a large audience very willing to hear that American tax dollars are being flushed away and/or spent on saving the fraud class. This is hardly revelatory. Condemning taxes is one of our driving narratives in the United States. The financial fiasco has given this storyline a new life.
I see no difference between what Rogers Ailes and his allies are allegedly doing with the tea parties and what Huffington, MSNBC and David Axelrod did last year with Obama. Creating, then tapping into an audience is what movements are. Leaders tell people what they ought to think - all the time. People then- for the most part - either incorporate or reject the information fed to them. This is not devious in and of itself. Those doing the astroturfing may have devious ends in mind to be sure. The astroturfing rules of the Obama Pods were devious by nature.
- This man is the answer to your frustrations. - You may not question anything about this man. If you do you are the enemy. - Anyone opposed to this man is stupid and probably evil.
By those rules the tea party "astroturfing" is positively ethical. Regardless, the proof will be in the pudding. If they are successful it is because they hit a nerve not because they created one to hit.
The alternative to this - dismissing and silencing all such top down organizing - is far worse. I would rather have people acting as if they still believe we live in a republic than sinking and seething into a realization that they may not. Then pitchforks, and later rocket launchers, come into play.
The fact is real grassroots movements rarely erupt in this country. When they do the distance between the eruption and violence is short. I lived through a spontaneous "grassroots" movement in Los Angeles after the Rodney King verdict. No one astroturfed those 4 days. And let's be clear - it started as a race riot - but within 12 hours it was a class riot. In most major cities we are closer to this happening now than anytime in the last 70 years.
If people believe we are being trashed, lied to, ripped off and conned by those taxing us I say: protest. Do it. Imaginatively and peacefully.
What Maddow and the rest really can't abide it not the impulse - it is that conservatives are behind it. I'm quite sure I would not agree with most of the "tea partiers" politics- but I support the fundamental right to protest.Labels: GOP, mocking liberals, paul krugman, protest, rachel maddow, tea parties
*Downtown Los Angeles: St. John's Episcopal Church will have an inclusion mass at 10:30 am on Sunday, then a march. It is near USC.
*TONIGHT from 6 to 9 pm in Silver Lake at Sunset Junction (Where Sunset blvd and Santa Monica blvd meet) is a rally and march. More info on both events here.
Also - because the "gays must understand and accommodate people of faith" meme is pissing me off no end I am linking a PDF of my church's marriage equality resolution here.
Some people of faith do not think religion and bigotry mix.
Religious belief DOES NOT justify or mitigate or soften bigotry. Not now - not during slavery, (the bible was used repeatedly to justify the enslavement of Africans.)
not in white supremacist churchs,
not in black separatist churches...
No way. No how. No one gets to hide behind religion on this one. NO ONE.Labels: all saints pasadena, no on 8, protest, st john's episcopal church los angeles, sunset junction
Bush thinks congress can't stop his escalation of the illegal, immoral, illogical, insanely expensive, truly stupid war he created so his friends could make money. Maybe. Maybe not. But people can stop it. And must. Labels: protest
|
|